Q: I searched the forums and online, but the only information I can find about the difference between Photoshop and Photoshop Elements is Adobes FAQ, which is not very specific. Can anyone here is a brief overview of the main differences and what I would miss if I bought elements instead of the full version?
Thanks,
Epsilon
Best Answer: PSE is built on PS. In other words, Adobe constructs a new version of PS then subtracts some things to make PSE.
The main differences are that CS4 has vector tools, additional controls for effects, painting tools (although a dedicated painting program does a better job – you can get the full version of ArtRage for $25) and can write actions. CS4 is also more hands-on than PSE. When you apply a bevel, a drop shadow or most of the other effects and filters you have to set all the parameters youself. Other than these differences the programs are very much alike.
The main points in favor of PSE are the number of automated fixes, the semi-automated selection tools, the pre-set-but-tweakable effects…It can do more for users and is better for beginners. (It still has a learning curve.) It can be less hands-on than CS4 but it doesn't have to be. I don't use the automatic fixes. PSE and CS4 have the same Filters and Effects. You can install plugins, actions, layer styles, brushes, etc. just like you can in CS4 to boost its functionality and customize it for your own needs. If there's something you need – like my occasional need for guidelines and text controls – there are cheaper alternatives like Paint Shop Pro or CorelDRAW which can supplement PSE.
There's also this to consider: Adobe always gives PSE users very good deals on Photoshop. If you outgrow Elements, you can always move to PS if you need to and you'll already know how the program works.
Re:Thanks a lot. Those answers gave me a much better idea of the differences.
Re:Photoshop elements doesn't have action scripts, mask support, and has only minimal batch processing support. Image effects like buttonizing and drop shadows are very limited. In Photoshop, you can specify how much of the effect and from which angle. PSE only gives you a couple preset effects to use. Also, the text tool doesn't have support for Smooth, Crisp, or Strong font properties. There IS an anti-aliasing option though.
I bought myself a copy for web design and it works fine for me. Every once in a while, I'll run into something where batch processing or action scripts would be helpful, other than that, I haven't had problems. It only cost me about $25 after rebates so I'm happy.
Re:It's a matter of degree – the real differnce is several hundred bucks!
Re:I actually used elements only for a short while but was pretty impressed with how much it is like the full version. For less than 1/5 the price it should do everything you need. If you do stuff that truly needs Photoshop 7 power you should probably already know you need it.
0 Comments.